Tesla Stock: Are Robotaxis and Humanoid Robots Enough to Maintain Its Valuation?
Tesla Stock – A £10,000 investment in Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA) just one month ago would now be worth approximately £9,190, marking an 8.1% decline. This drop in value reflects a combination of market volatility and external pressures facing the company, despite a small appreciation of the pound. Currently, Tesla’s shares are hovering near two-month lows, shedding 30% from their peak of $488.54 in December 2024. While still 43% above their November 2024 levels, this sharp fall has raised concerns about the company’s valuation and future prospects.
Tesla’s Decline: Internal and External Pressures at Play
Tesla’s recent slump can be attributed to a mix of self-inflicted and external pressures. One of the main factors is the distraction of CEO Elon Musk, who is deeply involved in other ventures, including his $97.4 billion bid for OpenAI and his role in the Trump administration’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE). These commitments have raised concerns that Musk’s focus on Tesla may be divided, leading to doubts about the company’s direction.
According to Morning Consult data, Musk’s consumer favorability has drastically declined, plummeting from 33% in 2018 to a mere 3% in January 2025. This sharp drop in popularity has raised questions about the leadership stability of the company and its long-term strategy.
Political and Trade Risks Impacting Tesla
Tesla also faces political risks that could affect its global operations. For instance, the Trump administration canceled a $5 billion electric vehicle (EV) charging infrastructure program, which had been set to benefit the EV industry. Additionally, new steel and aluminum tariffs threaten to disrupt Tesla’s supply chain, which is heavily reliant on China.
Another significant concern is the increasing competition from Chinese automaker BYD, whose new $9,600 EV features self-driving technology that competes directly with Tesla’s own offerings. With BYD’s aggressive pricing strategy, Tesla’s market dominance in the EV space is being challenged.
Financial Struggles: Missed Targets and Analyst Downgrades
Tesla’s Q4 2024 earnings fell short of both profit and revenue targets, which led analysts to revise their 2025 revenue forecasts downward by 5%, now projecting $116.8 billion. This marks a troubling trend for a company that once thrived on market expectations for future growth. To add to the company’s woes, there has been a notable increase in insider selling, including a $20 million stock dump by Musk’s brother Kimbal Musk.
Tesla’s Volatility: More Than Just a Car Manufacturer
Despite its size and presence in the automotive market, Tesla’s stock behaves more like a speculative growth stock. The company’s beta of 2.1 means its stock is twice as volatile as the S&P 500, highlighting the instability that comes with investing in Tesla. For comparison, traditional giants like Apple and Microsoft have much lower volatility. Since the inauguration of Donald Trump on January 20, 2025, Tesla’s stock has dropped 21%, with a 6.3% drop occurring on February 11, 2025. Such sharp declines are typically not seen in large, established companies, underscoring the speculative nature of Tesla’s stock.
Tesla’s Overvalued Status and Future Prospects
Tesla’s price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio currently stands at 139.1 times, which is an eye-watering 820% premium compared to the sector median of 15.1 times. Even more concerning is its forward price-to-earnings-to-growth (PEG) ratio of 7.98, implying that investors are paying nearly $8 for every $1 of expected earnings growth—409% above the industry average. By comparison, traditional competitors such as Toyota have a PEG ratio well below 1.5.
The company’s massive valuation is largely based on unproven technologies, such as robotaxis and humanoid robots, which have yet to be commercialized on a meaningful scale. Tesla’s robotaxi pilot program is set to launch in Austin this June, but its self-driving technology is already being outpaced by BYD’s DiPilot system, which is already in use in China’s $9,600 EVs. Meanwhile, Musk’s Optimus robots are still far from reaching a practical, marketable stage, with no clear timeline for their commercial release.
Tesla Faces an Uphill Battle
Despite being a leader in the electric vehicle market, Tesla’s current volatility and sky-high valuation have made it a risky stock for many investors. The company faces significant competition, political pressures, and internal leadership distractions that have led to its recent slump. While Tesla’s technological promises and market dominance in certain areas make it a formidable player, the company’s future will depend on how it navigates the uncertainties surrounding its leadership, market positioning, and unproven technologies. Investors and market observers will continue to closely watch Tesla’s ability to rebound from this period of turbulence.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Cryptocurrencies and stocks, particularly in micro-cap companies, are subject to significant volatility and risk. Please conduct thorough research before making any investment decisions.
Leave a comment